Why does Donald Trump offer citizenship and the undocumented do not celebrate?

Published in Elfaro.net on

Advancing Justice President and Executive Director, John C. Yang, Comments on Trump's Latest Plans

Washington, UNITED STATES. "To this proposal of white supremacy we say: No," says Greisa Martinez Rosas, a Mexican who crossed the Rio Grande with her parents when she was seven years old and today is an activist in United We Dream, the largest network of young migrants in the United States. .

"We reject this proposal and urge others to do so," says Jonathan Jayes-Green, an Afro-Panamanian co-founder of the black undocumented group UndocuBlack Network.

"What the White House is selling to the American people is nothing more than a wish list in favor of the natives, which would reduce the number of migrants, especially people of color," says Venezuelan-born activist Juan Escalante.

However, the plan proposed by the White House on Thursday to naturalize up to 1.8 million migrants within 10 to 12 years is "very generous" for many sectors of American society. Why do the potential beneficiaries complain?

Trump created this crisis"

Martínez Rosas, Jayes-Green and Escalante are 'dreamers' (dreamers). This is how migrants who arrived irregularly in the United States when they were children are known and can reside temporarily thanks to the Decree of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA), which grants them a temporary residence permit.

The program was created by former President Barack Obama in 2012, to alleviate the failure of the 'DREAM Act', an acronym in English of the Law of Promotion for Progress, Relief and Education for Foreign Minors, which was not approved in 2010 in a Congress dominated by Republicans.

But Trump in September revoked the DACA, which will expire definitively on March 5, 2018, passing the post to Congress to legislate on the sensitive issue.

The regularization of the 'dreamers' thus became the stone in the shoe of the crucial budget law. So much so that the lack of a solution on the issue caused a week ago the partial closure of the federal State for three days.

The Republicans in power and the Democratic opposition finally passed a provisional financing law, which expires on February 8, with the commitment of the Republican majority in the Senate to act in relation to the DACA.

"This crisis was created by Trump," says Frank Sharry, director of America's Voice, an organization that advocates immigration reform in the United States, accusing the president of seeking to "demolish" the Statue of Liberty, a symbol of migrants they forged the United States.


"Do not be fooled by the 1.8 million," adds Sharry, stressing that Trump "seeks to divert attention from the huge number of anti-immigrant proposals he seeks to launch."

Some 690,000 people were beneficiaries of the DACA when it was repealed, according to official figures. But according to the Migration Policy Institute, about 2.1 million would be eligible as dreamers, out of the total of 11 million undocumented immigrants that the Pew Center estimates to be in the United States.

The Trump roadmap, which Congress will begin to debate these days, includes regularizing the 'dreamers', but in exchange for measures that strengthen the repression of the undocumented.

It requires 25,000 million dollars to build a border wall with Mexico, Trump's flagship electoral promise that the 'dreamers' consider a racist project, a waste of money and an attack on the environment.

It also eliminates the lottery of residence visas ('green cards'), implemented in the 1990s to favor diversity, and ends with the "chain migration", limiting it to the spouse and minor children.

"Those who say they value the family should recognize our families. We can not go back to a time when the United States only accepts European migrants, "said John Yang, director of AAJC, a defense group for Asian-Americans, who recalled that more than 130,000 Asians qualify as dreamers.

"This is a clear attempt to exchange one group of vulnerable lives for another," says Katharina Obser, of the Women's Refugee Commission refugee rights group.

Activists say they will not be taken as "hostages" to institute "xenophobic" immigration reform, and ask Congress to pass legislation that protects them without harming others.